Skip to main content

The Obligatory (Not) E3 2023 Round-Up, Part 2: Sifting through the Slop

Alright, it's been a while but we're back again to cover the PC Gaming Show, the Xbox Showcase and the Ubisoft Forward. After this, that's it, that's all, we're done here. PC Gaming Show The Most Questionable Stuff 3. Road to Vostok (???) Choosing to look down on a game for overt familiarity from the word ‘go’, even if all it has done at this point is have its existence announced to the world, is not inherently an act to be proud of. Much of gaming iterates and builds upon what came before, much of the medium as it stands (for good or ill) exists because someone looked at a past work and were inspired to develop their own take on the material. How many excellent games would cease to be if people decided that “it’s just a clone of X” was a valid argument in itself? I establish this now to make it clear that I do not roll my eyes at Road to Vostok for taking the form of a sparsely-populated shooter set in a post-apocalyptic wilderness area… but rather because it loo

Thoughts on... STAR WARS: THE LAST JEDI

Some Background, First

Much like a lot of folks I know, and I imagine a significant portion of the populace, I grew up with Star Wars. I distinctly recall being in the theatre as a toddler, back in 1999, seeing The Phantom Menace for the first time. I also remember being woken up in the car by my mother, having (apparently) fallen asleep while watching The Phantom Menace, soooooo… yeah.

The prospect of a Sequel Trilogy excited and thrilled me in a way I’d not felt in a long while - seeing that first teaser of The Force Awakens, where the Millenium Falcon comes swooping into frame over the deserts of Jakku, was nothing short of breathtaking. I’d loved the Original Trilogy, I had a certain abiding fondness for the Prequels, I adored the games, I liked the spin-off books I’d read (Tales of the Bounty Hunters and the early Rogue Squadron books, primarily). Point is, I cheer at the mere thought of new Star Wars. 

The Force Awakens was quite pleasant, all told; not quite EMPIRE-level greatness, not even RETURN in terms of quality, but a solid revival of the franchise’s spirit that left room for growth and promising developments. The next year, Rogue One stepped up to the plate as a surprisingly promising spin-off film, offering a bit darker and a bit more scrappy of a take on familiar Star Wars fare than usual. And so when the early trailers for The Last Jedi came around I felt hopeful - cautious given the franchise’s issues with maintaining quality over time, but hopeful nevertheless. 

Not everyone seemed to share that same hope, especially once the film came and went. To put it excessively mildly, the reaction to Episode VIII was astounding in its fervor… and its toxic divisiveness. Some criticism of the film I could grasp well enough (Star Wars isn’t for everyone, art’s subjective, not every creative decision sits well with an audience, so on and so forth), but there was a not-insignificant portion of folks who were just straight-up assholes about it. Harassing the cast and crew, berating director Rian Johnson at every opportunity, going to extreme lengths to both miss the apparent point of the film AND attempt to “wish” it out of existence… that shit’s cruel and misguided.

There were a lot of reasons I’d put off watching it - work putting me in a position where I just didn’t have the time, not wanting to jump into the conversation while it was still hot and heavy, et cetera. But I think the biggest one was I wanted to be mentally prepared for it, giving myself time to set expectations and not oversell or undersell the film to myself. Judge it on the merits, and all that. 

So then… to my thoughts.

My Thoughts

I felt like soaring with all kinds of emotions after watching this film. The Last Jedi is, to be absolutely clear, a wonderful and masterful work from a team that I’d already expected to be solid in their output. It charts the way forward for Star Wars (as a brand, as a narrative, as a wider franchise) like few other works have before. And it reminded me of why I fell deeply, utterly in love with these films in the first place.

The key to why it works - besides the time-tested combo of Good Director, Good Cast & Crew, Good Script - is rather simple: it gets Star Wars. It’s sufficiently critical and introspective about various aspects of the universe and mythos, like the place of the Jedi and the role of a Rebellion given all kinds of profiteering and political machinations. At the same time, it also understands why those things came to exist, and sets the stage for what they must become in the times ahead.

It’s damn near spelled out in a number of key scenes, such as old Master Skywalker’s fireside chat with the spirit of Puppet Yoda (YAY!) and various moments during the Canto Bight sequence. It’s challenged by the understandable but ultimately misguided rhetoric of both Luke and his nephew Ben Solo (Kylo Ren) - the former believing that the Jedi’s admittedly innumerable failures means they should cease to exist for the good of the galaxy and the Force, the latter driven to murderous and anarchic intent by his view that the galaxy’s systems and traditions AS A WHOLE are to blame for evil.

The Last Jedi recognizes and explores the need for change as an explicit theme, as a way of thinking in and out of narrative. It permeates the character arcs - Rey overcoming her feeling of worthlessness to find her own purpose in life, Finn letting go of fear and wholeheartedly embracing the fight for freedom, Poe learning to think before he leaps and thus showing his potential as a budding leader of the Rebellion. Even Luke’s last stand, buying time for the last of the Resistance to escape from their base on Crait, is driven very much by his renewed understanding of what a simple act of heroism and compassion can mean for people.

Systems and archaic ways of thinking cannot stand, yes, but to destroy them without thought or concern for consequence is foolish. Moreover, as the film argues without ever having to stop the action to outright explain it, it’s dangerous for the very people one seeks to help. The Last Jedi makes a compelling case for thoughtful evolution of cultures and of causes, for the idea that if the Jedi and its ilk are to endure then they must change with the times and learn from the past… not abandon all hope and forget what has come before.

Beyond that aspect, The Last Jedi has a great deal to offer its audience. It’s often breathtaking in its cinematography, depicting such sights as the salty surface of Crait or the exquisitely gauche riches of Canto Bight in great detail. Care is taken in staging shots and scenes, colour and lighting coming alive in ways much unlike past films in the franchise. The soundtrack soars and broods where it must, lending weight to action and evoking these potent emotional responses at every turn. It’s a film of great beauty and great substance in many regards.

No one was quite prepared for this to be the thing that stamped director Rian Johnson and co’s names onto Star Wars. But by god, by every god, I am glad it turned out so well. Whatever comes next from this creative team, whatever Johnson may have up his sleeve for his own trilogy and beyond, I can safely declare myself eager and hopeful for the end result.

This mattered. This will endure the test of time, gods (or maybe Force) willing. Thank you.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Obligatory (Not) E3 2023 Round-Up Part 1: Sony & Summer, Oh My!

On March 30th, it was made public that this year's Electronic Entertainment Expo would be cancelled. This decision was attributed to the strain of the ongoing plague and an increasing number of studios electing not to attend.  This would be only the latest in a line of troubles faced by the long-running trade show. Setting aside that two of the previous three shows were also cancelled for similar reasons, the 2021 expo faced criticism for pivoting to an online-only interface that had technical issues, lacked vital information and came across as irrelevant in the face of individual game publishers' digital showcases. The last pre-pandemic show in 2019, meanwhile, was embroiled in controversy over the leaking of personal information for thousands of media professionals attending E3.  It's not unthinkable that this latest cancellation will prove to be the fine point capping off a larger industry narrative: the decline and impending death of E3. Nevertheless, the gears of ind

Critical Round-up Volume II: An Assortment of Films

It's been a hot minute since I've had cause to discuss and critique films on here. Granted, my bread and butter tends to be writing about video games, so that's where my focus tends to gravitate. But that doesn't mean I don't view my fair share of movies OR that I lack things to say about them. So, to keep things varied around these parts, let's take a look back at some films I've had cause to view as of late...   Thor: Love and Thunder The Basic Premise Some time after Avengers Endgame , Thor has set out in search of a new purpose while continuing to aid various worlds in his own unique way. He soon discovers a new threat in the form of Gorr the God Butcher, a malicious figure who (as the name suggests) has set about murdering all the gods in the known cosmos. When Gorr successfully carries out a bold attack - and child abduction - on the colony of New Asgard, Thor sets out on a rescue mission alongside Asgard's new king Valkyrie, his old rock-based fr

2023 in Gaming: The Most Promising Games

Last time, we talked about the least good looking games set for release in 2023. This time, it's more hopeful as we examine the handful of titles that - based on available visual and written information - appear primed for success this year. Starting from the bottom... The FOURTH MOST PROMISING: Killer Klowns from Outer Space Releases sometime in the first quarter of 2023 The Basic Premise: We know at this point that it closely resembles the 1988 sci-fi comedy of the same name, bringing with it the unique design of the clowns themselves. Beyond that and the basic concept of a competitive multiplayer game being at its core, not much is readily apparent. How Am I Feeling? I'm newer to the fandom for this particular 1980s cult curiosity, but I adore its goofy digressions and visual gags that serve to give life to an otherwise familiar monster movie structure. Killer Klowns is delightfully singular in its twists on well-worn sci-fi horror tropes, and it runs exactly long enough